Gadamer's hermeneutics is also called the hermeneutics of indoctrination, indoctrination is quite important in Gadamer's hermeneutics, and indoctrination is the starting point and beginning of Truth and Method.Rorty absorbed and developed Gadamer's idea of indoctrination to form the philosophy of indoctrination.There are certain similarities between the two ideas of indoctrination,but there are also differences.This paper will focus on five aspects to compare the two indoctrination ideas, namely, the theoretical background and direct origin of indoctrination, the concept of indoctrination, the concept of truth in indoctrination, the epistemological problem of indoctrination,and the orientation problem of indoctrination.By comparing the above five aspects,a clearer perception of Gadamer's and Rorty's ideas of indoctrination is gained.

Indoctrination;Gadamer;Rorty

[1] He Weiping. An Outline of Gadamer's Hermeneutics of Indoctrination[J]. Journal of Wuhan University (Humanities Edition),2011,64(02):44-54. [2] Gadamer ,Hong Hunding (Translator). Truth and Method I [M].Beijing: Commercial Press, 2010 edition, p. 8. [3] Huang Xiaozhou. Gadamer's Hermeneutics of Indoctrination and Ancient Practical Wisdom[J]. Journal of Wuhan University (Humanities),2012,65(05):22-29. [4] Huang Xiaozhou. Gadamer's Hermeneutics of Indoctrination and Ancient Practical Wisdom[J]. Journal of Wuhan University (Humanities),2012,65(05):22-29. [5] Gadamer (Author),Hong Hunding (Translator). Truth and Method I [M]. Beijing: Commercial Press, 2010 edition, p. 24. [6] Gadamer,Hong Hunding (Translator). Truth and Method I [M].Beijing: Commercial Press, 2010 edition, p. 25. [7] Gadamer,Hong Hunding (Translator). Truth and Method I [M].Beijing: Commercial Press, 2010 edition, p. 24. [8] Rorty,Li Youzhu (Translator). Philosophy and the realm of nature [M]. Beijing; Commercial Press, 2017 edition,p.7. [9] R. Rorty,Lv Xiang (Translation). Philosophy without Mirrors[J]. Philosophy in Translation,1987(03):31-39. [10] Chen Huaxing. Indoctrination and Philosophy of Indoctrination[J]. Fudan Journal (Social Science Edition),1994(06):50-54. [11] Rorty,Li Youzhu (Translator). Philosophy and the realm of nature [M]. Beijing; Commercial Press, 2017 edition,pp. 376-377. [12] Rorty ,Li Youzhu (Translator). Philosophy and the realm of nature [M]. Beijing; Commercial Press, 2017 edition,p.380. [13] Gadamer ,Hong Hunding (Translator). Truth and Method I [M].Beijing: Commercial Press, 2010 edition, p. 20. [14] Gadamer,Hong Hunding (Translator). Truth and Method I [M].Beijing: Commercial Press, 2010 edition, p. 20. [15] Huang Xiaozhou. The Phenomenological and Historicist Implications of Gadamer's Indoctrination Thought[J]. Journal of Guangxi University (Philosophy and Society),2009,31(06):98-102. [16] Zhang Yinghui. Discussion on the Concepts of "Bildung" and "Indoctrination"[J].Journal of Central South University(Social Science Edition),2012,18(01):44-47. [17] Gadamer,Hong Hunding (Translator). Truth and Method I [M]. Beijing: Commercial Press, 2010 edition, p. 22. [18] Gadamer,Hong Hunding (Translator). Truth and Method I [M]. Beijing: Commercial Press, 2010 edition, p. 21. [19] Huang Xiaozhou. A study of Gadamer's hermeneutics of indoctrination [M]. Beijing: People's Publishing House, 2016 edition, pp. 30-31. [20] Rorty,Li Youzhu (Translator). Philosophy and the realm of nature [M]. Beijing; Commercial Press, 2017 edition,p.378. [21] Gadamer,Hong Hunding (Translator).Truth and Method I[M]. Beijing: Commercial Press, 2010 edition, p. 2. [22] Peng Qifu. Reconstruction of Dialogue Dialectics in the Mode of Practical Philosophy - Re-investigation of Gadamer's Philosophical Hermeneutics[J]. Tianjin Society,2019(06):40-48. [23] He Weiping.Practical Philosophy in Gadamer's Truth and Method--Analysis of the Interpretation and Significance of this Book on Aristotle's Ethics[J]. Journal of Seeking Truth,2010,37(06):22-29. [24] Gadamer,Hong Hunding (Translator).Truth and Method I[M].Beijing: Commercial Press, 2010 edition, p. 17. [25] He Weiping. Epistemology and hermeneutics-a historical perspective[J]. Journal of Humanities, 2004, No. 3. [26] Rorty,Li Youzhu (Translator).Philosophy and the realm of nature[M]. Beijing; Commercial Press, 2017 edition,p.378. [27] He Weiping. An Outline of Gadamer's Hermeneutics of Indoctrination[J]. Journal of Wuhan University (Humanities Edition),2011,64(02):44-54.

DOI： https://doi.org/10.62639/sspjiss03.20240104

Published： 2024